Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Canberra Comment 
 COP 15: Vegetarian mafia descend on Copenhagen 

COP 15: Vegetarian mafia descend on Copenhagen

THEY'RE waiting for unwitting passengers stepping off the train and heading for the climate talks - the vegetarian mafia thinking they can solve the world's pollution problems by turning everyone off meat.

Funny little people, often dressed as chooks or cows (or last night, a prawn) and are everywhere handing out show bags full of paraphernalia espousing a veg-filled, meat-free diet.

They claim western diets need to be re-thought because emissions from livestock are killing the planet.

Backed now by their own television station which infiltrates press conferences with "journalists" asking loaded questions about how best to stop livestock production, the message from this group is that livestock is the main driver of deforestation and the largest single source of water pollution.

They say livestock emissions are the most potent source of greenhouse gasses, arguing livestock produces more greenhouse gases than the world's transport sector.

But scratch the surface and dig a little deeper into their show bags and their anti-meat campaign just doesn't stack up.

Last month, environmental scientist Tim Flannery debunked a lot of the common arguments used against livestock in the carbon and climate debate at an environmental forum in Sydney.

Instead he said large animals like cattle and sheep were essential to restoring the health of the planet and reducing greenhouse gas levels.

Dr Flannery said 99 per cent of gases we breathed were produced by plants and animals but about 200 years ago humans discovered fossil fuels which, "combined with our destruction of living things like forests and soils, had pumped tens of billions of extra tonnes of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere".

Dr Flannery said large farm animals helped retain fertility in the land and recycled carbon.

He did say they had to be better managed and bred to maximise their environmental benefit while reducing methane gas emissions.

It doesn't take a lot of prodding to uncover that rather than having an environmental problem with livestock, many of these people are actually just opposed to the slaughter of animals.

That is a perfectly valid and personal view they are entitled to hold.

Just leave it off the climate change bandwagon.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size



RELATED COVERAGE

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Why the "mafia"! Governments give a high amount of support to the livestock industries because of the economic benefits and exports. The climate change and environmental implications are simply ignored. People just don't want to know the truth and it is the basic reason why our government, driven by one-issue - the economy, will never really be able to manage climate change. Tim Flannery has a conflict of interests with this one and he is not being totally honest and objective.
Posted by Vivienne, 16/12/2009 7:38:42 AM, on North Queensland Register
Good article, but bad research source. Given too much emphasis on incorrect informations about the true damaging effect of animal farming. If you were to do your research correctly, animal agriculture factor for more than 50% of the green house gases.
Posted by jon, 16/12/2009 8:09:28 AM, on North Queensland Register
I'm very sad to see that so much scientific research on global warming that has been done by renowned institutions such as NASA and the United Nations did not make any impact on individuals like Lucy Knight or Dr Flannery. I believe the evidence of the effect of meat consumption on global warming are too great to be ignored or made fun of. Now is the time to act fast while we can. The natural resources of the planet are dwindling and we do not have enough water to cater for the meat industry. They should pay high taxes for the quantity of water they use to produce the meat that ends up in our plate. In fact the meat consumers also should pay taxes for the damage they are causing to the planet by supporting this industry. It is about time that we all become responsible for what we are creating or in this case, destroying: our beautiful planet.
Posted by Concerned Citizen, 16/12/2009 8:24:55 AM, on North Queensland Register
Thank you for your article, Lucy. However, I cannot find Dr. Flannery's remarks that you speak of. Could you please send a link so I can read his full statement? I know that other esteemed scientists are very clear in stating that stopping to eat meat is the single most effective thing we can do to stop global warming. Dr. Rajendra Pachauri, the Nobel prize winning head of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has spoken out consistently on this subject, including at the present Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen. Dr. James Hansen of NASA also has expressed that vegetarianism is the right direction to move in. Lord Nicholas Stern, chair of the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment at the London School of Economics has also stated that shifting to a plant-based diet is the most effective measure we can take to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. In view of the reports of these emminent scientists, I very much appreciate the efforts of those that are bringing this urgent issue to the public eye. I hope people will research themselves, and see that if we want to keep this planet, we must stop all raising of animals for meat. Thank you.
Posted by saveourplanet, 16/12/2009 8:37:00 AM, on North Queensland Register
Please help to hold down the greenhouse gas emission.
Posted by r-m, 16/12/2009 8:37:52 AM, on North Queensland Register
There are so many worldwide respected reports on the harms that livestock industries have done to environment as it is number 1 contributor to greenhouse gases emission. The UN's Livestock's Long Shadow (2006) reports is just an example. Why do you think Sir Paul McCartney calls for Meat Free Monday? Is he a "mafia" too?
Posted by Steve Green, 16/12/2009 9:39:22 AM, on North Queensland Register
Dear Lucy, I think you need to do more research. There are so many people backing the veg diet because of the ecological benifits. People such as: Rajendra Kumar Pachauri - chair of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Sir Paul McCartney. Dr. Andy Thorpe. Heidi Hautala – Member of Finnish Parliament. Dr. Chen Shen Hsien - Director General of Water Resources Agency, Formosa (Taiwan). Jens Holmi - Member of the European Parliament The list is endless. Go Veg, Save the planet!
Posted by Steven F, 16/12/2009 10:06:28 AM, on North Queensland Register
Dear Lucy, I wonder how you managed to become a 'reporter'? My 5 year old daughter has a better understanding of climate change than you!
Posted by Julie, 16/12/2009 10:35:37 AM, on North Queensland Register
Mafia?! :D It was freezing cold in cop these days, I saw these Mafias standing outside Bella Centre for hours to give out well-researched and presented information on climate change and the link to our diet. And i happened to find out they're volunteers, paying for their own flight and accommodation in cop. We need more Mafia like these people - sacrifice for the others, for what is right. Lucy, may light be with you (as our shared name indicates), so you can see clearer. pls read those materials in the bag, with your heart. God bless.
Posted by lucy, 16/12/2009 11:47:47 AM, on North Queensland Register
Go veg Go green, save the planet...that's all I want to say...that's all we need to do :)
Posted by Begu, 16/12/2009 12:28:45 PM, on North Queensland Register
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11  |  next >
Canberra Comment
Climate change and the global warming might be the big issues on the national agenda, but for Canberra bureau chief Lucy Knight there's no hotter place than Canberra in 2009 as the Labor Government enters a difficult phase of its new-found power.

Most popular articles

Ray White Rural IRRIGATION CONFERENCE 2010
 
Rural Bookshop
 
NQR Facebook
 
NQR Twitter


 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...