News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Finance 
 Stewart takes a swipe at renegade AWB directors 

Stewart takes a swipe at renegade AWB directors

4/09/2008 6:19:00 AM
AWB chairman Brendan Stewart has questioned the "ethical and moral" positions of four fellow directors continuing to draw fees after a shareholder vote effectively scrapped their positions.

His comments came yesterday as holders of AWB's restricted A-class shares voted to scrap the shares, with 77pc of votes cast supporting a change in the company's constitution that will redeem and cancel the stock.

A-class shares can only be owned by wheatgrowers, are non-transferable, receive no dividends and have to be surrendered when farmers stop producing wheat.

Their only real power is to nominate a majority of grower-representative directors to the AWB board. Mr Stewart has argued that this left AWB at the mercy of agri-politics and prevented it from appointing directors with broader experience for the changed environment in which AWB operates since its "single desk" wheat trading licence was removed.

Yesterday's meeting was a resumption of the gathering adjourned on August 21, where proxy voting figures showed the resolution would be narrowly defeated, with 74.7pc of holders of A-class shares supporting the change — just shy of the 75pc needed.

This time, AWB managed to lift the percentage of eligible shareholders voting from 27pc to about 44pc.

That meant the number of shares voted was a little more than 50pc in total.

Of the proxies in the hands of AWB before the final vote, 70pc were in favour of cancelling the A-class shares, 22.8pc against and 7.2pc were open proxies — meaning the chairman could vote them at his discretion.

Wheat Growers Association president Bob Iffla said after the meeting that opponents of scrapping the A-class shares would consider whether to challenge the result, but said they would have to consider the overwhelming number of grower shareholders who had supported the change.

Mr Stewart limited questioning at the meeting, saying that the issues had been widely discussed at the previous shareholder gathering.

That did not stop activists for both sides challenging Mr Stewart and the grower-nominated directors over their stances on the change.

Later, when asked whether the A-class share directors should have any say in the company's future, Mr Stewart said those directors needed to consider whether "it continues to be ethical and moral to draw remuneration" when the majority of shareholders had rejected their position.

Speaking after the meeting, Mr Stewart said the split had not created a dysfunctional board, and the company was able to make commercial decisions.

AWB's board met soon after the vote to consider a date for the next extraordinary meeting, likely to be held next month, to approve a new constitution.

AWB shares finished the day 7¢ better at $2.97.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1



Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
It really is a bit rich don't you think having Bredent Stewart question the ethics of fellow grower directors after he has presided over the biggest scandal in australian agriculture and been at the helm whilst AWB shares have dropped from nearly $7 to $3...unbelievable!!!! Isn't it time he moved himself on - who said he is the most qualified to run the company - didn't he get elected there too by fellow growers????
Posted by Stewart on 5/09/2008 7:49:05 AM
Brendan can not talk about ethics. He was at the wheel when the company did the deal in Iraq which almost destroyed the company, had a huge effect on our world wheat sales and lost us the single desk. He is also the one who refused to release so called Legal and Privilaged infomation to the Cole enquiry which may have shown who new what including himself and some high flying politicians. The whole time refusing to resign. Talk about ethics? This whole debacle cost the industry and shareholders millions and this man calls others unethical. Honour your promise Mr Stewart and resign today. "God save the AWB because nothing will save Bredan Stewart".
Posted by Bring back cole on 5/09/2008 8:29:11 AM
The four directors who Mr Stewart is treating with contempt are men of honour and courage and will be remembered as such. The whole ballot had a bad smell about it and when growers realise how they have been duped into forfeiting control of their company with no compensation they will be embarrassed and angry.
Posted by Jock on 5/09/2008 8:51:12 AM
Ethics - what a joke. How can someone talk about the ethics of others with one of the worst scandles in Australian history still warm and a very questionable voting process just carried out. This "ethical" company has cost growers millions of dollars and Stewart is now standing up talking this rubbish. I cannot understand how our so called regulators can let this fiasco continue. Stewart get real and get out!!
Posted by Astounded on 5/09/2008 9:31:49 AM
The desk is dead! Let's move on. The future of the wheat industry is good!
Posted by young farmer on 5/09/2008 11:00:17 AM
I personally take offence when it is suggested that farmers were duped into "forfeiting control". We made the smart decision, let's move on.....
Posted by vicfarmer on 5/09/2008 12:58:43 PM
Young farmer you are in for a rough ride and a hard education on reality. Those of us who have been farming for a long time now have a fair idea of what is in store for grain growing in Australia. Farmers have been taken right out of the supply chain where we used to have a strong presence. The strength in numbers and the strong farm organisations we used to have are gone and are being run by leaders more interested in their wallet than what is good for the majority. I wish you well. But if you think the future is good then you better keep your eyes open.
Posted by Bring back cole on 8/09/2008 6:57:39 AM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
AWB chairman Brendan Stewart.
AWB chairman Brendan Stewart.

Q: Is there a future for young people in agriculture?

Yes
(63.4%)

No
(30.9%)

Undecided
(5.7%)

Total Votes: 722
Poll Date: 31/08/2008

11/12/2008 | Farm lobby groups will decide next week whether the future of farm representation will stay as it is or be broadened to bring in the big end of town.
NQR Subscriptions
 
Rural Bookshop
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...