News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Plea for NSW lakes water to flush 'dying' Murray mouth 

Plea for NSW lakes water to flush 'dying' Murray mouth

28/07/2008 9:23:00 AM
Two of the four biggest lakes in the huge Menindee Lakes water storage system in NSW are full to the brim.

Now the South Australian town of Goolwa wants some of it downstream to flush out the salt and acid turning the Murray mouth into a stinking bog.

In a country gripped by drought and climate change, the stricken SA community wants to use water reserves that flowed into NSW from the summer Queensland floods.

Menindee Lakes, on the Darling River, is under half its capacity, with the two largest lakes bone dry since 2002.

But Lake Pamamaroo and Lake Wetherell last week held 531 gigalitres, significantly more than the 10 megalitres a year that the nearby community of Broken Hill needs for human use.

Alexandrina Council's Mayor, Kym McHugh, last week renewed calls for 400 gigalitres from Lake Pamamaroo and Lake Wetherell to be released to SA to save a river system he says is dying from the mouth up.

"We see that water up in the Menindee Lakes, and we know that we have to think about Broken Hill's water needs," said Mr McHugh, whose council covers Goolwa and Hindmarsh Island at the Murray mouth.

"But we think the Federal Government should be buying, or making arrangements with the NSW Government to have some of that water released down into the lower lakes."

But without direct Federal Government intervention, the water will never be seen by SA because the maximum capacity of the two lakes is held at a level low enough to keep them under NSW control.

While NSW argues it took the largest lakes out of commission because they were shallow and prone to evaporation, the Goolwa community notes it also keeps the system beyond reach of the Murray Darling Basin Commission.

The Commission can allocate Menindee Lakes water to SA and Victoria when reserves reach 640 gigalitres.

"It is an absurdity that there is a trigger level of 640GL stored in Menindee Lakes, because the current way they are operating, you are never going to make it," said SA MP Adrian Pederick, whose electorate of Hammond covers communities along the River Murray.

The proposal to release Menindee Lakes water, which Mr McHugh put to the Commission's ministerial committee at a forum in Murray Bridge last week, has had a mixed response.

SA Water Minister Karlene Maywald said the State's water position was so dire overall that Menindee Lakes water might have to be used to keep Adelaide going if no more rain fell.

The CSIRO's chief scientist, Bill Young, told a SA parliamentary committee this month that more than 50pc of any water released from Menindee Lakes would get through to SA.

But while the use of the water for Goolwa would be positive for the Murray mouth, he said, the cost of diverting the water from other uses had to be taken into account.

Mr McHugh said urgent federal intervention was needed because the deterioration of the Murray mouth — where the exposure to air of acid sulfate soil was creating sulphuric acid, or "rotten egg" gas, on the mud flats — showed how sick the system was.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1



Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
South Australians need to understand the reasons why the Menindee Lakes scheme no longer fills. A large part of it has effectively been moved upstream into private dams on cotton properties in northern NSW and QLD. Governments need to buy some of these farms and their water rights. A start could be made by buying Toorale Station near Bourke, with a reputed 180 Gigalitres in storage. It is for sale now.
Posted by Barney on 29/07/2008 10:14:00 AM
Of course there is always an alternative, and in this case it may be a longer term solution. Let the sea water reclaim the lakes and return them to their natural state.
Posted by Jimmy on 29/07/2008 12:44:33 PM
Perhaps a better suggestion could be that if the pollies actually understood the situation instead of going off half cocked to oil a squeaky wheel. Government leglislation has caused the problem so can you actually believe the ones that created the problem are capable of fixing it?
Posted by RW on 29/07/2008 2:41:10 PM
think hard about it Jimmy. the natural state of the river is that the last water in the system ends up in the 2 lakes cos they are the lowest point of the system. Then, the Murray mouth only closes when there is no flow, 3 times in a 100 years. Wave action from the Southern ocean means the mouth can never stay open while there is no flow. Remember, 3 times in 100 years. What is Natural?!!! you don't really understand wave action and river flow if you think it was a completely salt lake.
Posted by Tommy on 29/07/2008 9:09:20 PM
I'm with Jimmy. Why can't South Australia think of reclaiming the lakes with salt water. After all it's only in the last couple of decades that the water was flowing through the mouth of the Murray again - at the expense of Victoria's farming community water. Are South Australia looking at any other alternatives at all or do they just want what someone else has?
Posted by Blind Freddy on 29/07/2008 9:19:27 PM
Blind Freddy must be just that blind. I wonder where he gets the idea the river has only flowed to the sea in the last 2 decades. Do some reading mate
Posted by Tommy on 30/07/2008 9:46:07 PM
It's great to see some water back in the Menindee Lakes System and we do not want to pump it to SA. This water is needed by Menindee and its surrounds and we really need more flows to fill the largest lake, Lake Menindee so that we can get back to the good old days and people with their lakeside shacks will have water again.
Posted by Brenton on 1/08/2008 10:48:12 AM
WE need another jimmy. This one broken. The lakes are in N.S.W . Not that far from broken hill. The coorong is in S.A. As for those with james, yes you're blind fred.
Posted by THE FARMER on 1/08/2008 3:52:47 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Lake Pamamaroo, near Broken Hill, brims with water. Photo: David Mariuz
Lake Pamamaroo, near Broken Hill, brims with water. Photo: David Mariuz

Q: Did you support the striking truck drivers?

Yes - they need fairer conditions
(80.7%)

No - they have disrupted business
(12%)

Undecided - more information needed
(7.3%)

Total Votes: 777
Poll Date: 28/07/2008

11/12/2008 | Farm lobby groups will decide next week whether the future of farm representation will stay as it is or be broadened to bring in the big end of town.
NQR Subscriptions
 
Rural Bookshop
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...