News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Something fishy about 60 Minutes ag chemicals story 

Something fishy about 60 Minutes ag chemicals story

19 Mar, 2010 02:14 PM
CHANNEL Nine program 60 Minutes is planning to run a story on chemical use within the Australian agriculture industry on Sunday night.

Under the title “Poisoned” on the show’s website, the program synopsis briefly outlines journalist Liz Hayes’ story which involves her visiting other countries and seeing the human effects from chemicals, including physical malformations and deformities.

The synopsis contains the line: “But what if we were to tell you that Australia's fruit and vegetables are sprayed with chemicals that are considered so dangerous they're banned around the world?”

The site goes on to say: “Liz met a young man with no eyes, saw fish with two heads and trekked to a village full of horribly deformed children. And visited a farm on Queensland's Sunshine Coast where the animals are dying.”

The program will feature an interview with Gwen Gilson, owner of the Sunland Freshwater Fish Hatchery on Queensland’s Sunshine Coast, which, in 2009 claimed spray drift from a neighbouring macadamia farm caused fish deaths and deformities within fish embryos.

At the time of the media frenzy surrounding the “two-headed fish”, neighbouring macadamia farmer Troy Ziesemer deflected accusations of spray drift saying sprays were used strictly in accordance with label instructions and were applied only when weather conditions and low wind-speeds ensured the chance of spray drift or run-off was highly unlikely.

The farm contains buffer zones comprising up to 16 rows of macadamia trees which had been left unsprayed to protect neighbouring properties from possible spray drift.

Mr Ziesemer said he was contacted by 60 Minutes but declined to comment until they had spoken to the Australian Macadamia Society (AMS).

According to Mr Ziesemer, that meeting did not occur and he has had no response to messages left with the show’s producer.

Biosecurity Queensland confirmed that the official report into the Sunshine Coast fish deaths will not be finalised until April.

The Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority (APVMA) also declined a request to appear on 60 Minutes on the basis that the final report was yet to be released, and that it was not yet known if chemicals were involved.

It did however provide a written statement in early February in response to inquiries from the program.

Farmonline understands 60 Minutes was offered to be shown around a successful Bundaberg fish farm which has operated for the past 25 years surrounded by macadamia farms, but the program did not accept the offer.

* 60 Minutes will screen on Sunday night at 7.30pm.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Well if you take Liz Hayes as a serios journalist so be it. It was not so long ago she was rolling around Sydney as drunk as a skunk on the arm of John Singleton causing all sorts of havoc. These investitagative journalists are usually gratifying theiw own inadiqucies in these boots and all expose sensationalist stories. I have seen calves with two heads in my abattoir 50 years ago in Devon that had never seen a drug or ant insetacacdes. In New Zealand someone spawned Derryn Hinch now there indeed was a freak of nature or itcould have been insecticides. elizabeth
Posted by Elizabeth Basualdo, 20/03/2010 4:40:16 AM
Ah interesting story. So Ms Hayes is at it again! Well no surprises there. She did a story in the Pilliga during the drought and actually asked the family to arrange the dead cattle bones / or stand near the dead cattle bones for the best effect. Dont mind that the family was suffering financial loss Liz - or the drought had them all carting water just to drink - dont mind that your incesant whining of how dry and hot it was would be encouraging to the farmers property you were on - its okay Liz - you are SO important, way above the rest of us on the land. Eat your imported food Liz - and your imported clothes on your back - in fact - hey Liz - why not leave Australia for good? Now there's an idea?
Posted by Country Vandal, 20/03/2010 10:17:54 AM
Okay all you defenders of Macadamia farmers, I challenge you to find a buyer for Gwen Gilson's property given the recent spate of deaths of her animals and the complete devastation of her hatchery business. At MARKET price. So she can move on and her neighbour can continue spraying whatever he likes into the air. I'm pretty sure you will fail. Who would buy that place now? And how do you explain this situation if it's not the introduction of chemicals recently via the macadamia farm. I love madamia nuts and loathe 60 Minutes, but I think instead of ridiculing Mrs Gilson and her tragic situation, why not try to find a way to resolve it so everyone's happy and no-one's health or animals health are at risk?
Posted by Jacki, 21/03/2010 6:55:18 PM
OMG. I aint taking any chances. I am not going to buy strawberries from Australia again. and any other vegetable I find in my coming google search. I cant believe anyone would even eat stuff with this on it. I am going to wait till the final report to make sure its found safe first. screw eating it now to find out it causes cancer or something later. I am no gambler.
Posted by Trav, 21/03/2010 7:01:25 PM
Well, I thank 60 minutes for this story. I will only EVER buy organic and I will encourage everyone I know to only buy organic. Farmers who use these chemicals are irresponsible and in my opinion should go to hell for such cruelty it causes to animals and people alike. I will be writing my thoughts to every MP and demand for these chemicals to be banned. I am totally outraged that they are considered safe when there is over whelming evidence that they are NOT!! What bloody country to we live in? I am not proud!!
Posted by Shellann, 21/03/2010 7:21:45 PM
the real story is why does it take years for our regulators to remove chemicals from our market that are banned in other leading nations including the kings of chemicals... the USA. Dieldrin was banned in most leading nations in 1974 yet we used it until 1989, bet the kids born with defects around Coffs Harbour would have apprieciated swifter action and I'm sure it will be the same for the chemicals mentioned in the Liz Hayes story...why does it take so long to remove these dangerous chemicals from our food chain when other advanced nations have removed them based on scientific evidence. Who funds our chemical registar?
Posted by haystack, 22/03/2010 5:32:08 AM
Food imported from China has been sprayed with chamicals like DDT and other nasties that have been banned here for years. They also use human fecies for fertalizer. Our food production here in Australia is both sustaignable and the best in the world. This is an unfortunate situation that is being sensationalized.
Posted by Drew, 22/03/2010 6:30:59 AM
It is time the general public were made aware of the toxic chemicals that are used in food production and storage. There is absolutely no way farmers, or chemical companies, can deny the dangers of using these dreadful chemicals. To attack the integrity of the messenger (Liz) is cowardly and totally unjustified. Back in the about the 1960's we used 24D on a paddock of wheat to control vetch / tare. Running in the paddock next door were a mob of merino ewes. At lambing many of these ewes had lambs with all sorts of deformity combination's. Some lambs had two to three sets of ears in various places on the head. No eyes, no bottom jaw and other ghastly deformity inflictions. From memory some were born alive, others were still born. There were no other deformities in any of the other mobs of sheep running in paddocks further away. We worked out the cause had to be the 24D spray drift at, or around the time of conception. Anyone with any savvy knows that many of the sprays used in food production are hormone mimic's and play havoc with individuals health and the environment. To deny this is being naive or just plain stupid.
Posted by ggwagga, 22/03/2010 6:56:07 AM
Right so 60 countries have banned this chemical because of the risk it poses to human life and here you are saying it's all false. It seems that self interest is driving this article and the following replies.
Posted by dave, 22/03/2010 6:56:56 AM
The last paragraph basically confirms how the only thing Liz Hayes is interested in is a sensationalist story.
Posted by JayDin, 22/03/2010 7:02:48 AM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
21 February, 2010
12 February, 2010
30 August, 2009
06 February, 2010
19 November, 2009
MULTIMEDIA
16 March, 2010
18 March, 2010
POLL
Q: Do you support the move to introduce an import risk analysis on beef from BSE-affected countries?

Yes
(74.6%)

No
(22.4%)

Uncommitted
(3.1%)

Total Votes: 389
Poll Date: 15 March, 2010

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC SJ



North Queensland Register







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...