News 
 National Rural News 
 Grains and Cropping 
 General 
 Turnbull backs the lifting of ban on GM crops 

Turnbull backs the lifting of ban on GM crops

21 Nov, 2008 11:15 AM
Federal opposition leader Malcolm Turnbull has said Western Australia's bans on uranium mining and genetically modified crops were "pure left-wing ideology" - and Premier Colin Barnett's lifting of both would be good for state and country.

The decision to end the ban on uranium mining earlier this week followed the Barnett government's decision to allow GM cotton to be farmed in the state, angering conservationists - but apparently delighting the Liberal leader.

In South Perth to meet local businesses, Mr Turnbull labelled the previous government's stance on both issues as irrational and illogical.

"One was the ban on uranium mining which was irrational and illogical, the second one was the ban on GM crop - in particular GM wheat," Mr Turnbull said.

"GM wheat is a godsend because what it enables you to do is to dramatically reduce the amount of pesticides you need to put on your crop.

"So it has been an incredible benefit not just to Australia but to the whole world.

"The previous Labor government here had some ideological hang-ups about GM crops, and about uranium mining that was simply not rational."

Mr Turnbull said fears over the possibility of more nuclear power plants in Australia should be allayed by the fact that bipartisan support would be needed before that eventuated.

And he said the use of uranium in other parts of the world would help battle climate change.

"Whether we have nuclear power plants in Australia – that is never going to happen without bipartisan support.

"We recognise that," Mr Turnbull said.

"But we know around the world, countries are expanding nuclear power in a large measure in response to climate change because it offers a zero emission form of emitting electricity.

"So how can we be serious about combating climate change globally and saying we are not going to mine uranium in Australia when there is so much demand for it?

"It was just pure left wing ideology on both those issues, and that is why it is great to have a rational government here in WA which is committed to sensible economic management in the interests of WA and in the interests of the nation."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I don't think anyone has grown GM wheat in Australia.
Posted by Don, 24/11/2008 7:22:54 AM
Is uranium mining zero emission? The mine site is likely to be radioactive for hundreds of thousands of years and the waste products will be around for as long. That's thousands of generations. Will the political situation be stable for the next thousand generation?
Posted by peter, 24/11/2008 8:49:16 AM
Surely Mr Turnball's position is a right-wing ideological one? He's in the ring slugging it out for big business and the 'free market' which seems to have gone AWOL of late. GM crops don't make any sense economically, environmentally or climatically. It takes years to develop a GE crop and the patents are tightly held and policed by corporations which answer to shareholders. It's about money not food. There are real concerns about the health and environment effects of GE crops which have not been answered and need to be. An even greater long-term risk is handing over our food security to multinational corporations. What if they go bust and we've out all our eggs in their basket? The idea that pesticides will be reduced by GE crops is a just spin. Crops engineered to be resistant to RoundUp, end up using more chemicals in the long term and crops engineered to manufacture their own pesticides, ie Bt crops, actually use more pesticides because the plant is producing it 24/7.
Posted by National Toxics Network, 26/11/2008 11:42:56 AM
looks like you are running out of arguments there national toxins network by making up some more imaginary ones. I have not grown gm crops this year yet but watched a few other friends and neighbours grow them. As well as going to many field days and talks about them it is easy to see that GE crops DO significantly reduce chemical use not to mention the chemical roundup (glyphosate) is one of the safest to use and does not stay around in the soil or plant near as much as current chemicals used on canola for example. Then these GE plants are very easily killed by the hundreds of other chemicals which we already use to kill them. Ask any farmer who has accidently not cleaned his boomspray out enough to decontaminate and the sprayed his canola crop how easy it is to hurt canola with the smallest amount of other chemical. They are only resistant to glyphosate. Therefore GE canola can use significantly less chemicals in the long and short term.
Posted by Damo, 28/11/2008 11:18:17 AM
Don, as far as I know, you are right. GM wheat trials are planned for Victoria and very little GM wheat (if any) is grown elsewhere in the world.

Either it is a misquote or Turnball made a mistake. He may have meant to say GM in general rather than specifically referring to wheat in that statement. Bold statement but it is overdue for the politicians to stop pandering to minority groups that force their anti-GM views on them.

Turnbull is a smart man with common sense and gauges public sentiment well.

Very interesting to read this article. Perhaps the tide is turning towards a more rational approach and debate.

Posted by james, 3/12/2008 5:33:31 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Malcolm Turnbull .
Malcolm Turnbull .
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
POLL
Q: Would you approve if the Federal Government put the budget into deficit in order to counter the effects of the global financial crisis?

Yes
(40.5%)

No
(54.8%)

Undecided
(4.7%)

Total Votes: 677
Poll Date: 17 November, 2008

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC FW



North Queensland Register







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...