News 
 National Rural News 
 Horticulture 
 General 
 Quarantine rules scare Filipino banana growers: Burke 

Quarantine rules scare Filipino banana growers: Burke

05 Mar, 2009 03:42 PM
Federal Agriculture Minister Tony Burke has defended the Biosecurity Australia recommendation to allow the importation of bananas from the Philippines.

He argues the quarantine conditions that would apply are so stringent that Filipino producers are angry with the decision.

Biosecurity Australia this week ruled that bananas could be imported into Australia, subject to numerous quarantine procedures being undertaken in The Philippines.

The news has also angered the Australian rural industry due to the risk posed by the possible importation of exotic pests and diseases.

"If the Philippines decide that they want any plantation to go down this path, Australian inspectors will be at the plantation and the Filipinos will be paying for the Australian inspectors," Mr Burke said.

"[They are angry] because the quarantine measures that have been taken to them are measures that don't apply to them for any other country other than Australia.

"The Filipino growers don't believe they'll be able to get any of their bananas into Australia."

However, Nationals Leader Warren Truss says Mr Burke and Biosecurity Australia have placed the disease-free status of Australia's banana industry at serious risk.

"Given the breadth of disease concerns about banana imports, and the disease-free status of our banana industry, growers have every right to be concerned," Mr Truss said.

"There is no evidence that the disease and quarantine issues that have stopped imports in the past have been resolved."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
It is normal for Australians to exercise their protectionist stance. While I symphatise with the local growers, we have to look at trade as a means of improving the lives of our neighbours.

Philippines is a poor agricultural country just trying to have its share of the global market where third world countries are not in the most advantageous position in relations to free trade.

Comparing the Philippines' agricultural trade profits with Australia is miniscule. How much of the meat and dairy products does the Philippines import from Australia?

Mindanao in the Philippines, where most of the bananas are grown, is home to the stronghold of insurgents and muslims. Providing them opportunities for change through a balanced world trade will have significant effect in the long-term in the fight against poverty and terrorism.

Posted by robbruce, 5/03/2009 5:34:23 PM
Once more Australia will 'import rabbits'.
Posted by jaimie, 6/03/2009 6:22:36 AM
rob bruce states that Mindanao is the stronghold of insurgents... 1) Obviously he has forgotten what happened in Bali! 2) The insurgents will not have to attack Australians physically, no, they can attack us financially when Mr Burke allows our Banana Industry to fall over with imported exotic diseases.
Posted by w.t.f., 6/03/2009 9:16:47 AM
I don't call for relaxation of the quarantine standards nor sacrificing the integrity of Australian agricultural quality and viability being world-class, all I am saying is to look at opportunities for trade between the two countries with a resonable terms as there are current trade between that country and Korea, Japan, New Zealand, Europe where quarantine standards are also high.

No, Bali and the like will never be forgotten but military or economic revenge will not help at all. The Abu Sayyaf, with links to Al-Qaeda in the Philippines have been holding hostage 3 International Red Cross Volunteers for weeks now. Philippine military have always had slow-paced success in that region because the local community either support, benefit or is a relative of these bandits. Food for guns, and in the long term development may win over false ideologies.

Posted by robbruce, 6/03/2009 9:59:56 AM
I am horrified that Biosecurity Australia could be so naive to think bananas could be imported from the Philippines without constituting a serious threat to our own industry. I personally witnessed mangoes being packed at a Filipino orchard for export to Sydney a few years ago with fruit flies stinging fruit both in the orchard and in the packing shed. Fruit were packed in closed trays on pallets for post-harvest hot forced air treatment before despatch. Trays were not ventilated and stacked so air could not circulate and distribute heat to the centre of the pallet meaning fruit fly eggs in those central fruit would not have been killed. It is probably good luck the fruit went to Sydney in the winter that we did not have an incursion of Oriental or Philippines fruit fly. If that is indicative of the quarantine standard the bananas will be subjected to, be prepared for a disease epidemic through our industry. Why is our government hell bent on shutting down all our agricultural industries?
Posted by RMB, 6/03/2009 10:16:47 AM
Good question. Queenslanders would remember the cost of managing the last Black Sigatoka outbreak which ran into millions and shut down numerous properties. Why do our governments insist on allowing imports of food produced here already? Imports which could threaten our local producers if requirements for treatment are not met, either through lax application, corruption etc. Governments of both hues continually try it on. Apples from NZ posing the risk of fireblight, imports from South America threatening our stone fruits - how long until they win their push to eventually allow in pig meat with the threat posed by Post Weaning Multisystemic Wasting Syndrome? We have it all in this country-one must wonder why we vote in people wanting to throw it all away.
Posted by Andrew Phillips, 6/03/2009 6:39:03 PM
To Andrew P and all: 1) By allowing all this diseased stuff in we level the playing field, no more unfair advantage for those cunning Ozzies. 2) The only way to eradicate diseases is to eradicate the host (see Citrus, Emerald QLD) No host, No Problems!! 3) No host, No Farmers, the Feds get to have the water and the land for a song!! 4) The sign goes up "Welcome to National Park Australia" Population 1,000 (EPA Personnel and Park Rangers) !! Got it Now!!!
Posted by Peter, 18/03/2009 6:28:26 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
MULTIMEDIA
05 March, 2009
03 March, 2009
04 March, 2009
POLL
Q: Should the Federal Government delay the introduction of an emissions trading system?

Yes - the economy is too vulnerable
(71.5%)

No - action on global warming is needed now
(25.1%)

Undecided
(3.4%)

Total Votes: 1007
Poll Date: 01 March, 2009

Most popular articles

Advertisement



North Queensland Register







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...