News 
 National Rural News 
 Livestock 
 News 
 Blame farm leaders: Crean defends new BSE policy 

Blame farm leaders: Crean defends new BSE policy

22 Oct, 2009 10:12 AM
IT was the Australian beef industry's lobbying that triggered this week's decision to change food policy laws, which until now blocked beef imports from countries which have had BSE, according to Trade Minister, Simon Crean.

Mr Crean says the changes will open up more opportunities for the Australian beef industry because the old rules were against science, open to challenge, and inconsistent.

He said the Australian beef industry urged the Government to make the changes because new science was available to back up a relaxiation of the rules.

"When you've got in place something that no other country in the world has in place, is against where the science has been in the past decade and is potentially open to challenge because of its inconsistency, they're all the trade implications," Mr Crean said.

Australia claims, especially, that it has a fast-response, effective beef traceback system.

Mr Crean said the risk of BSE coming to Australia as a result of this decision was "practically nil".

"It is negligible at 0.02 per cent chance in 50 years," he said.

"If you say that that's the basis by which we stick to an outdated policy, I'm sorry I don't agree with that.

"And if you've got the industry saying a far greater risk is we get wiped out from the current rules, then we had to change.

"It's what the industry wanted rectified and urged us to change."

Mr Crean said the previous Government had the science and knowledge to go ahead and make these changes "but squibbed it".

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size


RELATED COVERAGE

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
If Mr Crean was about to have an operation and had a 0.02pc chance of survival, I wonder if he would go ahead. Any risk to our disease-free status is too big to take. As for having in place rules that no other country has, what are we doing with our Emmissions Trading Scheme? Just that. Those in glass houses etc....
Posted by Jim Gunn, 23/10/2009 5:16:04 AM
I don't believe the beef industry was fully engaged in this debate - it just sounds like politics and we, the producers, will suffer long term.
Posted by tj, 23/10/2009 5:54:51 AM
tj is right. It's typical petulant ALP politics targeting "land-owners" - nothing less. Mr Crean is a socialist dinosaur.
Posted by AJ, 23/10/2009 7:41:52 AM
Crean expects people to believe that the beef industry really wants to open up their own domestic market to foreign competition, bulldust. Why do they talk down to us like this? The ALP is out of touch with what the Australian public knows and understands.
Posted by Lil Kevie, 23/10/2009 8:09:54 AM
Mr Crean has missed a fundamental point. If Australia accepts meat from countries that have had BSE and that country gets a subsequent outbreak, all Australia's meat sales would be decimated.
Posted by Mal Peters, 23/10/2009 8:32:19 AM
I work in the industry and when I got to work this week it came up and bit us all on the backside. Like hell the beef industry was consulted. No one in their right mind would have backed this. Just another free trade under handed deal. What happens if we do get BSE??? There goes Australias natural biosecurity quarentine speel to the rest of the world's markets.
Posted by Farm girl, 23/10/2009 9:30:43 AM
Funny. No other country has NLIS. Double government standards as usual. I assume by "industry" he refers to NFF, MLA etc which don't represent most farmers anyway. I hope the local processors are taking notes on this subject!!
Posted by John Michelmore, 23/10/2009 10:20:24 AM
I'm sure this is exactly what the Australian beef industry had in mind!! Wake up Mr Crean, this is why we are so cautious when reforms are put on the table! Usually serves someone else's purpose. Another political deal that will see Australia suffer. What is wrong with you ALP? What is your objective? Why would the beef industry risk one of its few international advantages? How stupid do you think we are?
Posted by Rebecca Dance, 23/10/2009 11:47:07 AM
There is also a "0.02pc chance in 50 years" you would catch Simon Crean eating meat that came from BSE-affected Countries. And who, in the beef industry would in their right mind, have lobbied for these changes?
Posted by Eat my Shirt, 23/10/2009 2:10:13 PM
Correction, Mr Crean, the 'beef industry' that you refer to is the Cattle Council, a group that is funded by your government through the levy reserve fund, or our forced beef tax. The Australian Beef Association was not consulted on this issue and we are against the chages made to the import regulations.

We were also against the signing of the USA FTA. Question who was it that initiated the off-the-shelf BSE rule in the first place.

Again, Mr Crean I suspect your 'industry".

Posted by Brad Bellnger, 23/10/2009 2:40:15 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Trade Minister Simon Crean
Trade Minister Simon Crean
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
20 October, 2009
21 October, 2009
MULTIMEDIA
21 October, 2009
POLL
Q: Who do you think is the best person to lead the Federal Liberal Party?

Malcolm Turnbull
(46.4%)

Julie Bishop
(5.7%)

Tony Abbott
(10.3%)

Joe Hockey
(23.6%)

Other
(14.1%)

Total Votes: 760
Poll Date: 18 October, 2009

Most popular articles

SPRAY AWARDS NEWS MREC



North Queensland Register







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...