News 
 National Rural News 
 Wool 
 General 
 Mulesing threatens woolgrower exit 

Mulesing threatens woolgrower exit

03 Sep, 2008 12:03 PM
Wool growers fear the 2010 phase out of mulesing will encourage some to exit the industry.

Currently growers have the option of mulesing in the traditional way and using pain relief or switching to clips fitted to the breach area of the sheep.

The clips - described as still being in the trial stage - are gathering momentum as growers assess their options.

Despite enormous pressure on Australia's industry from animal welfare groups to find alternatives to mulesing, some growers are not convinced a phase out is the answer.

And others have stated that if a halt to mulesing was mandatory they would stop growing wool.

Wal Merriman, Merryville Merino Stud, hosted a mulesing clip demonstration at 'Beverley', Boorowa, NSW, this week, where about 100 growers viewed sheep being fitted with the clips.

Traditional mulesing backed up with Tri-Solfen as pain relief was also demonstrated.

Brothers Gus and Alan Coles, 'Glencoe', Reids Flat, run 10,000 sheep and they don’t believe the clips are the answer to mulesing in their operation.

"Today is the first day we have seen the clips used and we are not impressed," Gus Coles said.

* Extract from a full story in The Land, NSW, September 4 edition.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
That is why we need to put genetic solutions front and centre. There are breeders out there with genetic solutions to mulesing and they can change a breeders flock quickly (like MPM). The last thing we want is people leaving the industry. Focus on genetics and get in bed with the people that have the answer, they are out there.
Posted by N. O. Mule Sing, 4/09/2008 8:23:44 AM
There is no doubt that clips are the way of the future. We have to move with the rest of the world where "blood letting" operations are a thing of the past and clips/rings a way of life. The clips do an excellent job and the clips of the future will be far more user friendly. If anyone thinks applying an anaesthetic to a mulesing wound does anything about the pain in a weeks time they have rocks in their heads.
Posted by Paddy, 4/09/2008 8:35:45 AM
Farmers and consumers need to put welfare first, then profit will follow.
Posted by Bernard L Brennan, 4/09/2008 11:05:02 AM
Wal and Chick and Co will keep trying to persuade people that mulesing with pain relief is acceptable to our customers. It isn't. C'mon Wal, time to put the industry ahead of short term politics. Time to get on board and stop the AWGA assault on the wool industry.
Posted by Sir George, 4/09/2008 1:08:07 PM
Oh please, if Wool Farmers cannot bring themselves to use pain relief to ensure their sheep suffer a lot less then there is something seriously wrong with these farmers. Who would want to deliberately mutilate an animal when pain relief is available. Where are these farmers ethics, would you do it to a dog or cat? no of course you wouldn't. Truth is the community is well aware of how cruel mulesing is and we all have very high expectations, as we should, as to how production animals should be treated. Soon there will be no room for inhumane farmers as the public will not allow it nor will retailers. Farmers that prefer to mutilate their sheep are just showing the world they have no respect for the animals they profit from. Right now there is pain relief available so bloody well use it.
Posted by Steff, 4/09/2008 1:26:17 PM
Those threatening to leave wool growing probably should. If they can't come to grips with market perceptions of their practices and seek ways of continuous improvement then they are doing themselves, their industry (and in this case, the sheep) a disservice. We selected Merinos and then bred them to maximise surface area around their breech. Having created the problem we now need a 21st Century solution that is in accord with the sensibilities of consumers. In the age of transparency there is no escape from scrutiny and accountability - simple approaches will be seen for what they are.
Posted by market forces, 4/09/2008 2:54:49 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
POLL
Q: Is there a future for young people in agriculture?

Yes
(63.4%)

No
(30.9%)

Undecided
(5.7%)

Total Votes: 722
Poll Date: 31 August, 2008

Most popular articles

SPRAY AWARDS NEWS MREC



North Queensland Register







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...