News 
 National Rural News 
 Wool 
 General 
 ‘Silver bullet’ mulesing mystery 

‘Silver bullet’ mulesing mystery

21/08/2008 11:03:00 AM
The mysterious ‘silver bullet’ expected to help resolve the mulesing issue is still a mystery to not only most woolgrowers but also many on the Australian Wool Innovation (AWI) board, the organisation developing it.

Last week, it was revealed that a new technology was soon to be announced that has the potential to be a universal alternative to mulesing, although very few details have been mentioned.

The injectable compound is commonly used in the food industry according to director Robyn Clubb and the project has been managed by a sub committee at AWI, involving director Kevin Bell who has been testing the product along with Chris Abell who is believed to be the inventor of the alternative.

Dr Bell told Rural Press at the WA Merino field days that the alternative is unlikely to have residue problems and therefore trials would not have to be conducted in that respect.

The promising collagenase injectable mulesing alternative, three years ago, failed to meet the strict meat residue limits demanded by authorities.

It also produced a wet scab.

It is unknown why the new compound would not meet the same limits under product registrations.

Dr Bell added he was confident the injectable would prevent breech strike, and that from his experience, growers would be more comfortable using it rather than the clips.

The new era of accountability and transparency lauded by AWI chairman Brian van Rooyen a fortnight ago, appears to have been short lived, with at least three and maybe as many as six of the nine member board first learning of the AWI assisted development from the media last week.

A similar lack of information shared amongst the board was seen when director Roger Fletcher learned of the Hugo Boss boycott of Australian wool earlier this year through his gardener.

Dr Abell was not commenting to Rural Press about the technology this week and along with fellow directors Wally Merriman, Roger Fletcher, Chick Olson and Ken Boundy, directed all questions to chairman Brian van Rooyen as is now company policy.

Mr van Rooyen failed to return calls from Rural Press this week.

He has been in West Australia at Merino field days along with Dr Bell and Robin Clubb.

Both Mr van Rooyen and Dr Abells are re-standing in board elections again this year, along with the three new proposed directors John Keniry, Ken Boundy and Robyn Clubb.

Dr Abell is also named as the inventor of the breech clip mulesing alternative but denied having any ongoing personal financial involvement in the clips when questioned by a Senate Estimates hearing earlier this year.

* More information on the new mulesing alternative in the special Merino feature this week in Rural Press weekly rural newspapers across Australia, August 21.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1


Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Sometimes this industry is its worst enemy. You`d think, with the importance of this issue, it would openly announce new developments, to ease the pain (pardon the pun) woolgrowers are going through with erratic information.
Posted by Marc on 21/08/2008 10:52:43 AM
So does this mean all the research dollars that are being spent on clips and other intradermal alternatives will stop immediatly because this new silver bullett is all we need?

How much more spin are AWI going to feed us? Why dosn't someone in the media ask AWI director Kevin Bell what he really thinks of the amount of research that his fellow director Chris Ables has done so far and has there been enough to warrant and declare it a silver bullet that is going to solve the mulesing issue outright.

I wonder if Kevin Bell is willing to put his reputation on the line and back the claims of the AWI chairman. Or is this just more spin before the AWI election, to make us think they are finally doing something with our levy money.

Posted by concerned wool grower on 21/08/2008 5:38:09 PM
You can understand why AWI don't want to release details yet, if you understand that some of the board appear to be a direct conduit to AWGA.

Inevitably, AWGA might want to use any information to play political games, to score cheap points before the next (AWI) election.

Always remember that AWGA were the group seen to trying to appease PETA.

Posted by Sir George Smith Hyphen Smyth on 22/08/2008 10:21:45 AM
I've just used tri-solfen and think it performed to the max. Clips suck.

Silver bullet? - I'll pass judgement when I see it.

But when the capeweed goes berserk and the spring flush is trying to kill your sheep with kindness and the blowies turn the sky black, thank god for mulesing.

Posted by THE FARMER on 22/08/2008 7:02:31 PM
Why are we drowning in politics and blame when all I really want as a farmer is to see a viable alternative to current mulesing practices. We were never going to get away with it forever so let's be pleased the ball is rolling. I too agree that clips suck!
Posted by emily on 24/08/2008 3:10:12 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
The 'silver bullet' injection is seen as being more convenient to use by farmers than the proposed experimental mulesing clip (pictured), which has been a central focus of AWI research.
The 'silver bullet' injection is seen as being more convenient to use by farmers than the proposed experimental mulesing clip (pictured), which has been a central focus of AWI research.

Q: Do you believe the public has a right to know on which farms GM crops are being grown?

Yes
(65.9%)

No
(31.6%)

Undecided
(2.4%)

Total Votes: 613
Poll Date: 17/08/2008

26/11/2008 | If we're serious about roo farming, we'll need to start with a breeding program and kangaroo EBVs for marbling and tenderness.
 
NQR Subscriptions
 
Horse Deals Australia
 
Rural Bookshop
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...